Wolchover – The missing mandate

Over the past several months a number of attempts have been made to stop Brexit using a legal challenge. They have all relied on aspects of David Wolchover’s comprehensive article:  “False Mantra of the “People’s Will” – The Case of the Missing Mandate”

None have so far managed to gain permission from a court (UK or EU) to proceed.

The likelihood of being able to proceed with one of the challenges and thus block Brexit has receded to such an extent that David Wolchover says in his article “Litigating Brexit at the eleventh hour”:

However, the outcome of one or other or both of two lawsuits respectively pending before the Divisional Court of the Queen’s Bench Division of the High Court of England and Wales, and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) may yet force the British government’s hand at the eleventh hour.

Neither could now directly result in an order cancelling the withdrawal of the UK from the EU, but the fall-out if the claims succeed could well change the course of events.

This was written in October 2017, so he could not know that the CJEU would reject the Shindler vs European Commission request for a judicial review as inadmissible on the grounds that the claimants had not been directly affected by the decision to open negotiations, as they were simply preparatory to a final act. They are looking into an appeal but there are very limited grounds available to them.

On Friday (7th December) there was an oral hearing in the High Court seeking permission to proceed with the challenge. Yesterday (10th December) the court refused permission to proceed on much the same grounds as it had done previously – the action was out of time.

The UK in the EU Challenge is looking at an appeal in order to get permission to proceed, but the current High Court term finishes in 10 days’ time on 21st December and the next term starts on 11th January.

If this challenge is successful it will still be for Parliament to decide what to do.

Given that there won’t be a result from the UK in the EU Challenge for some weeks, probably well into the New Year, the key factors are now the ruling by the CJEU that the UK can unilaterally revoke the Article 50 notification and what happens in Parliament now that the Government has scuttled away to find new way to dress up the unacceptable deal it has agreed with the EU.

In reality the government keeps on kicking the can down the road, apparently this is part of Theresa May’s methodology.

Perhaps she should pay some attention to David Davis, who in some previous incarnation seems to have been quite astute:

Project managers who believe that closing down a project will wreck their careers are tempted to carry on in the hope they will have a slight chance of saving their reputations. Both courses carry the risk of disaster for those responsible for a project, but one—abandonment—is often far better for the company.”

New Projects: Beware of False Economies”, published in Harvard Business Review (March 1985)

But perhaps, as Theresa May has already sacrificed her reputation, she considers that the consequences for those who hold her responsible don’t matter one iota.


The People's Challenge - logoWe value your support. Just keeping track of the campaigns and challenges that have objectives that match our own takes time and effort, much of what we do costs money that we can only afford to spend with the financial support of people like you.

Many people have contributed not once but multiple times and we know that there are practical limits on what people can do. Whether you can make a contribution (click on the image above) or not please spread the word among your contacts and on the social media.

Our aim is to help people see what’s going on, understand what they are, or aren’t, being told, and decide what is the best outcome for the UK: an outcome in the national interest, protecting fundamental citizenship rights and ensuring Parliament and not the executive is sovereign.

There is still a long way to go and there are no guarantees about what the outcome will be. The only thing that is certain is that if we stop trying we will lose.

To help protect our fundamental rights, and support Parliament in safeguarding them, please support us so we can maintain our campaign and make your voice heard.

Please share this article as widely as you can, thank you very much for your support.

Published by Grahame Pigney on behalf of The People’s Challenge Ltd.

This entry was posted in Article 50 negotiations, Brexit, Meaningful Vote, The Millions in the Margins, The Three Knights, What is Best for the UK? and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s